Breaking a Weight Loss Plateau
I know all about how annoying a low carb diet weight loss plateau can be.
In 2008, I began to change my eating habits in order to address some serious health problems.
I also wanted to lose the excess weight I had accumulated over the years while eating a poor diet full of processed junk food. It took several years, but I finally overcame my weight struggles, and as of March, 2012, I'm down 77 pounds.
The Most Common Causes of a Weight Loss Plateau
Here is my opinion, born of my individual experience, on the most common causes of a weight loss plateau.
If someone is following a ketogenic diet, and not losing weight, or the weight loss is inconsistent (going down one week and up the next), the dieter is most likely:
- Eating more carbohydrate than they think (fruit, nuts, and yogurt are the particular culprits here). I call this carb creep.
- Eating more calories than their body can handle without storing (this is usually the result of a very high fat intake - for me, too much dairy). Although I feel eating very low carb with lots of saturated fat is the healthiest way to eat, I've found for myself, I have to cut back on my fat intake in order to lose weight. I think once you reach the weight you want to be, you can add the fat back in reasonable amounts.
- Not exercising in a way that increases insulin sensitivity to the muscles. (The problem here is that for people with a broken metabolism, long, slow exercise doesn't work well - it has to be high intensity exercise, which uses all the glycogen stored in the muscles, and makes them more insulin sensitive. This would be once or twice a week bouts of heavy weight lifting, sprints, etc. Not every day walking on a treadmill.)
In addition, these issues can also be at work, alone or in combination:
- The person has a food sensitivity which is not being addressed. For instance, some people find that dairy products stall weight loss, or perhaps gluten in some form is being eaten (low carb pasta, protein bars or some other processed low carb food).
- The person has a very broken metabolism, and it will take time, and a commitment to do whatever it takes to fix the metabolic issues, especially when it comes to improving insulin sensitivity. This includes keeping the amount of carbohydrate consumed very low (I have to stay below 16 grams of carb per day to maximize weight loss), and avoiding foods and other substances which are known to spike insulin without necessarily increasing blood sugar. These include gluten, aspirin, non steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, casein protein from dairy products and coconut oil.
- The person is not being as consistent on the program as they think they are. Consistency over time is key, because it takes about 3-4 days to get into ketosis. If you kick yourself out with a cheat day, it will take that long to get back into ketosis. Now, at that point, almost a week has passed where no fat burning was occurring. If you are weighing yourself once a week, this can be disheartening, as that cheat day will have put 4 pounds of water back on, and it will be another 3-4 days before weight loss starts again. What seems like a weight loss plateau is really just a delay because of the time it takes to get back to ketosis.
- Accountability is lacking. Consistency, I think, is helped if you have a way to be accountable to someone, and you track your food intake and results each day to help you stay on course. I measure and track everything, (food intake, exercise, blood sugars) in a program called Fitday and on an Excel spreadsheet. If you don't do this, it is just too easy to let the carbs and calories creep up. It's a pain, but if you really want to make your weight goal, I think it's necessary to record what you are eating, and use this information to stay on plan.
- Sometimes, the body may just be adjusting itself after a period of intense weight loss. I've read in several articles that the body will replace lost fat with water, as it adjusts to weight loss. Then all of sudden, it will release the extra water, and the dieter will experience a "whoosh" in weight loss - say 5 pounds in two days.
- Protein intake may be too high. Too much excess protein, say in excess of 1.5 grams per kilogram of lean body mass, can have the same effect on blood glucose as carbohydrates, and this can be a "hidden" factor for a weight loss plateau.
A higher protein intake is encouraged during the first 3-4 weeks of a ketogenic diet. But after the body becomes keto-adapted and is burning mostly ketones for fuel, protein intake should be lowered to between .8 - 1.5 grams per kilogram of lean body mass. (If you exercise a lot, you can go to the higher end of the range.) Try cutting back on protein and adding a little more fat to your diet, while staying at a calorie deficit. For more info, see my daily protein requirement page.
- Paradoxically, you may not be eating ENOUGH calories or you are exercising too much. The body slows down its metabolism in response to a lack of food or excessive amounts of exercise.
Dr. Steve Phinney did a study in 1988 which showed that when people exercised more than an hour a day, their resting metabolic rate dropped by as much as 15%. There are at least two other papers which report the same outcome to a regimen of excessive exercise.
This doesn't seem to fit the logic of breaking a weight loss plateau, but you could try adding 300-500 calories of fat and protein to your daily count for a few days, and see what happens. And if you are exercising hard every day, reduce the amount of time you spend exercising and give yourself permission to rest a day or two during the week.
- You may be eating too often. Try going for longer periods without eating. This "intermittent fasting" works well for some people, as it allows the blood sugar and insulin to return to baseline levels before the next meal. For instance, instead of having 5 small meals a day spaced out over 8-10 hours, have most of your calories in a 6 hour window, say from noon until 6pm, and then don't eat again until the next day at noon.
- There may be a lack of a micronutrient, especially if you aren't taking any supplements. Try taking a balanced multivitamin once a day. Have your vitamin D levels checked and bring them up if they are low.
- Finally, and this is most important, the success of losing weight and improving health is about learning new habits and sticking with them. If you decide that your new eating habits are a permanent change, it makes it easier to weather the occasional weight loss plateau.
I know now that I can never go back to eating my "old" way. All of the health problems and the weight will just come back if I do. And after all the work I've done to fix my broken metabolism, that would be really self-destructive.
If you are experiencing a weight loss plateau, just hang in there. Honestly evaluate your diet and exercise program, tweak where you can, and try to wait it out.
Done with Weight Loss Plateau, back to Home
Back to Best Way to Lose Weight
More on Insulin Resistance and How To Reverse It